| COBSCOOK URCHIN OPTIONS | January 2005 | ||
| Draft Plan Recommendation | Lubec Meeting Recommendation | Eastport Meeting Recommendation | |
| Manage as Sustainable Fishery? | |||
| Yes | Yes | Yes | |
| Boundary of a Cobscook Urchin Zone? | |||
| Bog Brook to Canadian border | Schoodic Point to Canadian border | No new zones | |
| Who can fish here? | |||
| Any current Zone 2 license holder can choose Cobscook zone and then fish only in that zone | Residents from within the boundary of the Cobscook zone | Leave the fishery the way it currently is | |
| Duration of Plan | |||
| Experimental fishery for three years | Experimental fishery for three years | Leave the fishery the way it currently is | |
| Governance: Representation on a Cobscook Council | |||
| Representatives elected from people who fish in the zone | Representatives elected from people who fish in the zone | Representatives elected from people who fish in the zone | |
| Governance: Power of Cobscook Council | |||
| Balance between decision-making authority and advisory capacity | Balance between decision-making authority and advisory capacity | Balance between decision-making authority and advisory capacity | |
| Governance: Relationship with Commissioner | |||
| Deal directly with Commissioner | Deal directly with Commissioner | Deal directly with Commissioner | |
| Governance: Legislative Authorization | |||
| Legislature should authorize Commissioner to work directly with Cobscook Council through rule-making | Legislature should authorize Commissioner to work directly with Cobscook Council through rule-making | Legislature should authorize Commissioner to work directly with Cobscook Council through rule-making | |
| Management Measures: Days in Season | |||
| Make decisions about Cobscook based on Cobscook data, use surcharge money from Cobscook on Cobscook research, consider voluntary logbooks | Make decisions about Cobscook based on Cobscook data, use surcharge money from Cobscook on Cobscook research, do not want mandatory logbooks | Make decisions about Cobscook based on Cobscook data, use surcharge money from Cobscook on Cobscook research, do not want mandatory logbooks | |
| Management Measures: Tote Limits | |||
| Consider a daily catch limit by volume | Do Not consider tote limits | Do Not consider tote limits | |
| Management Measures: Closed Areas | |||
| Consider rotating closures, permanent spawning sanctuaries and research closed areas | Consider rotating closures, permanent spawning sanctuaries and research closed areas | Do Not consider closed areas | |
| Gear Modification | |||
| Experiment with low impact gear | Do Not consider gear modification | Do Not consider gear modification | |
| Conservation Hours | |||
| Consider using conservation hours | No clear recommendation | Continue to consider conservation hours | |